1800s
1. 1820 -1822 John WIlson
2. 1823 - 1824 Charles Sherman (Grand Master, 1824)
3. 1825 - 1826 William Irvin (Grand Master, 1825)
4. 1827 Thomas Cushing
5. 1828 - 1830 George Sanderson (Grand Marshal 1826)
6. 1831 - 1838 William J. Reese (Senior Grand Warden 1830-31, Deputy Grand Master 1833, Grand Master 1834-42)
7. 1839 - 1843 George Myers (Grand Treasurer 1837-1842)
8. 1844 Michael Z. Kreider (Grand Orator 1843, Senior Grand Warden 1846, Grand Master 1847-1849)
9. 1845 - 1847 Michael Daugherty
10. 1848 - 1850 John McClelland
11. 1851 - 1853 Virgil Shaw
12. 1854 George L. Eckert
13. 1855 Virgil Shaw
14. 1856 John McClelland
15. 1857 - 1860 Virgil Shaw
16. 1861 - 1862 Simeon Bickford
17. 1863 - 1865 John McClelland
18. 1866 - 1868 Phillip Wagenhals (Deputy Grand Master 1869-1870)
19. 1869 - 1870 William Noble
20. 1871 - 1872 Horatio G. Trout
21. 1873 Virgil Shaw
22. 1874 - 1875 Summerfield D. Eckman
23. 1876 Virgil Shaw
24. 1877 - 1878 John H. Gross
25. 1879 Summerfield D. Eckman
26. 1880 Monroe Palmiter
27. 1881 Horatio G Trout
28. 1882 - 1883 George W. DeGrummond
29. 1884 - 1886 William W. Obaugh
30. 1887 - 1888 Christian Gaiser
31. 1889 Summerfield D. Eckman
32. 1890 - 1892 John J. Wolfe
33. 1893 - 1897 Christian Gaiser
34. 1898 - 1899 James. T Pickering
1900s
35. 1900 - 1901 Thomas C. Coates (13th District Lecturer 1902-1905)
36. 1902 - 1903 Joseph P. Hershberger
37. 1904 L. Thomas Unks
38. 1905 Hiram F. Repass
39. 1906 C.S. North
40. 1907 John Graybill Reeves 33° (Grand Historian 1909-1920)
41. 1908 J.L. Graham (13th District Lecturer 1909-1910)
42. 1909 P.K. Shaw
43. 1910 W.A. Meikle
44. 1911 F.L. DeLong
45. 1912 John Harold Reeves
46. 1913 - 1914 Roi DeLancy (13th District Lecturer 1927-1932)
47. 1915 W.A. Thompson
48. 1916 L.E. Martin
49. 1917 H.C. Watson
50. 1918 John W. Barnes
51. 1919 - 1920 Curtiss L. Berry
52. 1921 Donald Shallenberger
53. 1922 Thurman T. Courtright
54. 1923 James C. Boice
55. 1924 Henry E. Rose
56. 1925 Hugh C. Baxter
57. 1926 Charles H. Drinkle
58. 1927 J. Wilbur Huddle
59. 1928 E.L. Campbell
60. 1929 George W. Robinson
61. 1930 Boyd W. Neff
62. 1931 Howard E. North
63. 1932 J.G. Zeisler
64. 1933 William D. Miller
65. 1934 Richard F. Hyde
66. 1935 James R. Bruney
67. 1936 C.C. Snyder
68. 1937 Lawrence C. Goodman
69. 1938 Leon W. Miesse
70. 1939 Thomas Gaylord Rose
71. 1940 Austin W. Secoy
72. 1941 Donald K. Bowling
73. 1942 Myles W. Turner
74. 1943 Thurman T. Courtright
75. 1944 Bruce M. Harner
76. 1945 George M. Metz
77. 1946 Clarence C. Wedge
78. 1947 Homer E. Petty
79. 1948 Richard W. Rowles
80. 1949 J. Walter Oberdorfer
81. 1950 Homer C. Helser
82. 1951 William E, Burt
83. 1952 Charles Ralph Keil
84. 1953 Roger William Engle
85. 1954 Albert Erwin Immel (13th District Deputy Grand Master 1955-1957)
86. 1955 Carlton H. Shank
87. 1956 Paul A. Scholl
88. 1957 Joseph Conrad
89. 1958 Dwight E. Walter
90. 1959 John H. Harrison
91. 1960 Dwight L. Kane
92. 1961 Leon E. Wolford
93. 1962 - 1963 Virgil Moore
94. 1964 Dan D. Gilkey
95. 1965 Royce E. Englander
96. 1966 William H. Douglass
97. 1967 Robert L. Gossett
98. 1968 Vernon H. Miller
99. 1969 Charles W. Dishon
100. 1970 Jon R.W. Armstrong
101. 1971 John C. Rogers
102. 1972 Robert A Winans
103. 1973 Larry R. Brenstuhl
104. 1974 Lloyd K. Hilliard
105. 1975 Gary D. Kauffman
106. 1976 James C. Draper
107. 1977 Richard A. Benadum
108. 1978 Robert L. Bennington
109. 1979 Don E. Miller
110. 1980 Edward D Lacey
111. 1981 J. David Johns
112. 1982 Ned S. Young
113. 1983 Robert D. Rosebrook
114. 1984 Thomas P. Martin
115. 1985 Nathaniel L. Hill
116. 1986 Jack W. Wright
117. 1987 Ralph O. Howes, Jr
118. 1988 S. Michael Oliver
119. 1989 Max L. Carpenter
120. 1990 Robert L. Phillips
121. 1991 Thomas G. Rose II
122. 1992 James M. Funkhouser
123. 1993 George A, Huffman
124. 1994 Wilson L. Browning
125. 1995 Ron Johnson
126. 1996 Donald B. Gardner
127. 1997 Delbert Bontrager
128. 1998 Russel Shell
129. 1999 Richard B. Van Gundy
2000s
130. 2000 Frank Stuck (13th District Deputy Grand Master 2011-2014)
131. 2001 Henry Hunt
132. 2002 Joseph Smith
133. 2003 Wilson L. Browning
134. 2004 Frank Stuck
135. 2005 Joseph Smith
136. 2006 Ernest W. Potts
137. 2007 John H, Searls
138. 2008 Edward B. Jackson
139. 2009 David E. Van Gundy
140. 2010 G. William Pursley
141. 2011 Michael L. McCandlish 13th District DGM 2016-2019; Junior Grand Deacon 2020, Senior Grand Deacon 2021, Grand Marshal 2022
142. 2012 Ernest W. Potts
143. 2013 Christopher D. Howard
144. 2014 James R. Bradford
145. 2015 Kevin J. Chase
146. 2016 Robin P. Leonard
147. 2017 Timothy E. Byers
148. 2018 Scott F. Snider
149. 2019 Danny T. Meenach
150. 2020 - 2021 Donald E. Casto
151. 2022 Timothy E. Byers
152. 2023 Billy B. Arnold, Sr.
153. 2024 Jonathan W. Allison